Physiology vs philosophy
Dissecting the Meanings of “Physiology” to
Assess the Vitality of the Discipline
Introduction
Physiology is one of the central disci-
plines on which all biological and medical
sciences were historically built (63). How-
ever, questions have recently been raised
concerning the relevance and vitality of
Write by #artistvishalsaxena
physiology and its ability to make a useful
contribution to biological and medical
sciences. Physiology is sometimes seen as
a discipline of the past that is “dying” in
the era of molecular biology and high-
throughput DNA sequencing (5, 50, 77,
96). However, close scrutiny would sug-
gest a less clear-cut picture. Not everyone
would agree with claims that the intellec-
tual discipline of physiology is dying, or
perhaps even already dead (97). They feel
that physiology has gradually “disinte-
grated” precisely because it has given rise
to a series of daughter disciplines, such
as neurosciences, immunology, and en-
docrinology (45, 74, 84). According to
this view, physiology is not so much
“dead” as a key element underlying
some of the most dynamic fields in the
biological sciences of today, including
the various -omics disciplines (120).
Some would even defend the view that
physiology remains a key field in mod-
ern-day biology and that it could per-
haps inspire renewal in other biological
disciplines, including molecular biology
and evolution (24, 51, 84, 86).
This conceptual review aims to intro-
duce physiologists to the philosophy of
biology and medicine. We argue here that
the claims made about the vitality and
utility of physiology depend heavily on
the definition of “physiology” adopted.
We distinguish between two families of
definitions of physiology found in the sci-
entific literature. Some focus on what
physiology is about—its object—whereas
others focus on how physiology is used to
study the biological reality—its method.
Within each definition, we will examine
the claims about the vitality of physiol-
ogy. We will consider the specific features
of physiology and whether it can continue
to play the integrative role it has played in
the past, with the capacity to unify diverse
biological approaches and experimental
data through common concepts or ex-
planatory principles. The results of this
conceptual investigation are shown in Ta-
ble 1.
In a nutshell, physiology can be viewed
from two different angles. If we use a line of
reasoning according to which each biolog-
ical science provides its own contribution
to the general functional explanation, then
physiology now coexists with other disci-
plines. On the other hand, as a science with
a specific object, the normal state of the
whole organism, characterized by homeo-
stasis, physiology is constantly reinventing
itself and will continue to make a crucial
contribution to other disciplines.
What is Physiology? Lessons
from the Historical
Development of a Discipline
Physiology has very deep, rich historical
roots providing important insight into the
current status of this discipline. A quick
glance at the history of physiology high-
lights three key debates:
1) Is physiology a general all-encom-
passing biological science, or, much
more modestly, simply the medical
investigation of the functions of hu-
man organs?
2) Can a single, highly general phe-
nomenon, such as homeostasis,
serve as the basis for integrating
knowledge about organisms?
3) Can physiology be identified with a
specific experimental method?
The first of these debates concerns the
status of physiology as either the broadest
biological science or, much more humbly,
a domain focusing primarily on humans
and their health. Physiology has a long
history. It has often been stressed that the
roots of physiology lie in the works of
Aristotle and Galen, and the term physi-
ology was first coined by the French phy-
sician Jean Fernel in his De Naturali Parte
Medicinae in 1542 (34). However, the
meaning of physiology has changed sig-
nificantly during the course of the history
of this domain. In the 18th century, in
particular, physiology had a broad, not
specifically medical sense, encompassing
animals and plants, very much like the
modern term “biology” (114). This tradi-
tion culminated at the start of the 19th
century with Dutrochet’s claim of the
unification of the general science of phys-
iology around phenomena such as osmo-
sis (1). At around the same time, Schwann
generalized the notion of metabolism,
and both of these scientists promoted the
idea of cellular physiology as a funda-
mental biological science applicable to all
living things (28). Cuvier, through his
conception of comparative anatomy
based on functional correlations between
organs, also contributed to this idea of a
broad science (3), and “comparative
physiology” developed in parallel with
“comparative anatomy.” However, the
term physiology has also been used in a
more restricted, medical, and human-
centered sense (22, 23), which has also
undergone major shifts in meaning. Phys-
iology was long considered a branch of
anatomy (54), particularly at the institu-
tional level, but also, to a lesser extent,
intellectually. However, in the 18th and
19th centuries, physiologists began to
show that function could not necessarily
be deduced from structure (13), thereby
relegating anatomy to an ancillary role
(63, 114). This development led to a large
number of physiology laboratories, de-
partments, and societies being created in
a general movement of liberation from
both the anatomical and medical con-
texts. This debate about the object of
physiology and its degree of generality
(i.e., is its object limited to human health,
or much more broadly, the entire living
world?) is still alive today.
The second debate concerns the possi-
bility of using a single phenomenon as
the unifying basis of physiology in gen-
eral. Historically, physiologists endowed
various phenomena with a central ex-
planatory power in the general scienc
I thik This article was published on the times of Mumbai university The famous artist of india This is Artist vishal saxena
Comments
Post a Comment